Does the legatee require acceptance to take ownership of a bequest?

General Chapter

Al-Mughni

Book of Bequests

Book 31 · Issue 1 · Bab 1

Open in Qurani

Primary text

Ownership of a bequest does not vest in the legatee except through acceptance, according to the majority of jurists, provided the legatee is a specific, identifiable person capable of accepting. This is analogous to gifts and sales, as the bequest constitutes the transfer of property to an owner capable of possession. Jurists supporting this view hold that the acceptance validates the transfer. If the bequest is for a non-specific group, such as the poor, the needy, or groups that cannot be enumerated (like Banu Hashim or Tamim), or for a public interest like a mosque or Hajj, acceptance is not required. Such bequests become binding immediately upon the testator's death because requiring acceptance from every member of an unascertainable group is impossible, similar to endowments (Waqf). Furthermore, ownership does not establish itself for the beneficiaries until they take possession, and their taking possession substitutes for explicit acceptance.

Supporting text

The jurists who stipulate acceptance state that acceptance does not require specific verbal declaration; rather, any act or statement indicating consent, such as taking the property, suffices, similar to the ruling in gifts and sales. Acceptance is permissible immediately or after some delay, but it must occur only after the testator's death, as no right was established for the legatee before that time, rendering rejection invalid beforehand.