What is the ruling when the outgoing party claims the incoming party forcibly usurped (ghasaba) the animal, and both parties present evidence?
General Chapter
Al-Mughni
Book of Claims and Evidences
Primary text
If the outgoing party claims that the incoming party usurped the animal and both parties present opposing evidences, the animal is ruled to belong to the outgoing party. This is the established position.
Supporting text
The position of Al-Qadi implies that the animal should belong to the incoming party in this scenario, but the first mentioned ruling is superior.