What is the ruling if the proxy performs Hajj from a location that is nearer than the required location for the obligation?
General Chapter
Al-Mughni
Book of Hajj
Primary text
If the proxy performs Hajj from a location less than the distance defining travel for shortening prayers (Masafat al-Qasr), it suffices because it is considered within the ruling of a close location. If the location is farther than this distance, it does not suffice because the full obligation was not discharged.
Supporting text
There is an alternative view that performing it from a lesser distance suffices but is disliked (Musi'), similar to one who was required to enter Ihram from the Miqat but entered Ihram from a nearer point.