What is the ruling on consuming the Hoopoe (Hudhud) and the Shrikes (Sard)?
General Chapter
Al-Mughni
Book of Hunting and Slaughter
Primary text
There are two conflicting opinions attributed to Ahmad regarding the Hoopoe and the Shrike. One opinion states that they are permissible (Halal) because they do not possess talons (dawat al-mikhlab) and are not considered repulsive (mustakhbath).
Supporting text
The second opinion attributes their prohibition (Tahrim) to the Prophet's (peace be upon him) prohibition against killing the Hoopoe, the Shrike, the Ant (Naml), and the Bee (Nahl). However, a general principle is established that anything that does not hunt with talons, does not consume carrion, and is not considered repulsive, is permissible.