Is a marriage contracted by a more distant guardian valid if the nearer guardian is present and the woman agrees without the nearer guardian's consent?

Primary text

The marriage is invalid if the more distant guardian contracts it while the nearer guardian is present and the woman agrees to it without the nearer guardian's consent. This is the position of Shafi'i. The evidence is that the right of guardianship is established through male kinship (ta'sib), and it does not become established for the more distant relative in the presence of the nearer one, analogous to inheritance.