What physical defects disqualify a sacrificial animal?

General Chapter

Al-Mughni

Book of Sacrifices (Uḍḥiyah)

Book 57 · Issue 6 · Bab 1

Open in Qurani

Primary text

There is no known scholarly dispute regarding the disqualification of four major defects: the overtly one-eyed animal (*a'wra' bain 'awraha*), the overtly sick animal (*maridah bain mardaha*), the overtly lame animal (*'arja' bain zal'iha*), and the extremely emaciated animal that lacks marrow (*'ajfa' allati la tunqi*). This is based on the Hadith of Al-Bara' where the Prophet (peace be upon him) listed these four defects as invalid for sacrifice. The overtly one-eyed animal is one whose eye has completely disappeared. The overtly sick animal is one whose illness visibly affects it, as this reduces its flesh. The overtly lame animal is one whose gait prevents it from keeping up with the herd to graze, thus reducing its flesh. The emaciated animal (*'ajfa'*) is one whose bones lack marrow (*naqiyy*) due to extreme leanness, leaving it mostly bone.

Supporting text

The interpretation of the sick animal being specifically the one with mange (*jarbaa'*) by some Shafi'is is a restriction without textual support, as the general meaning of sickness affecting flesh and value should apply. Minor lameness that does not lead to separation from the herd is permissible. If the eye has white spotting but is not entirely gone, the sacrifice is valid because the defect is not 'overt' and does not reduce its meat.