What is the ruling if an animal designated for sacrifice (after initial purchase) is found to have a defect?
General Chapter
Al-Mughni
Book of Sacrifices (Uḍḥiyah)
Primary text
If the animal was designated for sacrifice and then found to be defective, the person is given the choice to return it or take the *arsh*. If the *arsh* is taken, its handling follows the ruling established for an excess value beyond the animal's worth. However, a strong opinion states the *arsh* belongs to the buyer because the designation (*ijab*) occurred when the defect was absent, hence the designation did not affect the right to compensation.
Supporting text
According to Abu al-Khattab's view, the owner cannot return the animal because his ownership was relinquished upon designation, akin to a situation where a buyer frees a defective slave and subsequently discovers the defect.