Is it permissible to spend counterfeit or debased currency (ghish)?

Chapter on Riba (Usury) and Exchange (Sarf)

Al-Mughni

Book of Sales

Book 12 · Issue 1 · Bab 3

Open in Qurani

Primary text

The preferred ruling is permissibility for spending debased currency if the people have mutually agreed upon it, similar to agreed-upon fiduciary money (fulus). This view is narrated from [Ahmad] concerning dirhams called Musaybiyyah, which were mostly copper with some silver, where he permitted it if it was an agreed-upon standard. The justification for permissibility lies in the fact that the components are known, there is no deception (gharar), and its widespread use across generations without objection suggests tolerance, avoiding undue hardship and harm. Furthermore, its purpose is clear and observable, unlike jeweler's dust. The prohibition is thus understood to apply only when the adulteration is hidden, leading to deception, which is the core evil prohibited by the Prophet's saying, "Whoever deceives us is not of us."

Supporting text

The second narration states that spending debased currency is forbidden, based on the Prophet's saying, "Whoever deceives us is not of us," and the prohibition by Umar ibn al-Khattab against selling Treasury waste (nifaya). Scholars of the Shafi'i school suggest permissibility if the adulterant has no intrinsic value, but hold two differing opinions if it does have value. The ruling of prohibition is often confined to cases where the debasement is hidden, leading to potential fraud against Muslims.