What level of prevalence or number of reports is required for testimony based on widespread knowledge (Istifadah)?

General Chapter

Al-Mughni

Book of Testimonies

Book 63 · Issue 4 · Bab 1

Open in Qurani

Primary text

The statement of Ahmad and Al-Khiraqi implies that testimony based on widespread knowledge requires that reports become numerous, heard from a large number of people sufficient to establish certainty (Yaqin). Al-Qadi in 'Al-Mujarrad' stated that hearing from two just individuals whose reports settle the heart is sufficient, as rights are established by the testimony of two. This aligns with the view of later Shafi'i scholars. The first view is consistent with the linguistic meaning of Istifadah, derived from the overflowing of water due to its abundance.

Supporting text

The view requiring only two trustworthy reporters contradicts the concept of Istifadah, as testimony based on testimony (Shahada 'ala al-Shahada) has specific conditions, whereas Istifadah requires only mere hearing without such prerequisites.